Cullen drops hint on priorities for task force

Finance Minister Michael Cullen has given a steer to the issues he thinks the Task Force on Financial Intermediaries should be focusing on.

Friday, April 22nd 2005, 8:05AM

by Rob Hosking

In a speech to Tauranga businesses, Cullen singled out concerns such as problems of conflicts of interest through commission-driven agents, transparency around fees and the roll-up of savings products with insurance products as having priority.

He also indicated he wants to see “an industry that provides a range of products suited to local conditions, that operates transparently and applies a high level of expertise while charging competitive fees”.

The task force, which has a wide-ranging ambit, has been mulling over the first batch of responses to its issues paper put out before Christmas.

The issues paper was a wide one, as was the consumer questionnaire put out about the same time.

The issues of commission sales versus fees appears to have emerged as a major issue from the first round of the task force’s work, but Cullen’s comments are the first time a minister has singled out the issue.

Cullen also indicated his next Budget – now less than a month away – will have quite a bit on savings, although two age-old panaceas, compulsion and specific incentives, are out.

“We are treading carefully, and seeking a path that does not rely too heavily on either the notion of compulsion or the manipulation of the tax system.

Compulsion can negate some of the economic benefits of savings – by stipulating a particular kind of investment – and also the social benefits “if there is not sufficient choice to promote education and wealth management skills”.

Tax incentives are distortionary – “by sequestering retirement savings in a special category, they can also make it difficult for households to take an integrated approach to all of their assets, including housing, education, and perhaps a business”.

Rob Hosking is a Wellington-based freelance writer specialising in political, economic and IT related issues.

« Managed funds outflow continues in March quarter

Sovereign takes regulation bull by the horns »

Special Offers