|
|
Spicers' Quarterly Strategy Paper
Spicer's Quarterly Strategy Summary paper looks at global investment themes, the outlook for individual sectors and our overall assessment of markets.
Wednesday, May 14th 2003, 10:46AM
INVESTMENT THEMES
This quarter, we focus on the following key themes:
- The economic implications of New Zealand’s high immigration.
- Global equity earnings.
The economic implications of New Zealand’s high immigration
Over the past year, there has been a marked increase in the rate of inbound migration to New Zealand. Contributing factors include: the growth in foreign student numbers, a high rate of permanent migration from Asia and South Africa, and a greater desire by expatriate New Zealanders to return home. It also appears that a significant number of short-term arrivals are becoming long-term residents after they reach our shores.
So, what are the implications for investors?
- Inflation may be high as the economy struggles to cope with an excess of demand for some services.
- House prices may be well supported and overall economic growth may be higher.
- The potential for interest rate cuts to boost business and consumer confidence is reduced in
an environment of persistent price pressures.
- Higher economic volatility could result.
New Zealand immigration trends have historically shown sharp changes in direction, and the transition from very strong migration growth to modest, flat or even negative growth could bring significant problems. There is no clear way to manage monetary or fiscal policy to smooth migration fluctuations or to offset the effect of these fluctuations on demand and prices.
Global equity earnings
Most comparisons of current share prices relative to 2003 prospective earnings put global P/Es at around the 14-15 times mark. Some commentators argue that trailing earnings, as opposed to prospective earnings, are the better measure and that on this basis P/Es are still too high at over 20 times. We are quite comfortable basing our views on prospective earnings and our current assessment is that valuations and the state of the corporate profit cycle provide reason for optimism about future equity market returns.
With depressed earnings having been the order of the day for the last two years, however, it is important to consider how a return to healthier rates of corporate profit growth can be achieved.
When reviewing the present state of the global profit cycle, it is significant that margin expansion is cited as a key driver of improved earnings. During the tougher times, one expects weaker firms to fall by the wayside, allowing those remaining to enjoy some improvement in their ability to hold and increase prices.
There are some good examples of this process inside different industry sectors. Telecommunications is an area that has recently seen a number of new entrants drop out. As a result, evidence of improved operating margins being enjoyed by the major service providers is now clearly evident. Close to home we are beginning to see a better return on equity performance from Telecom New Zealand, while our international equity managers also report improved operating performances from companies such as Vodafone.
Another sector where similar trends are evident is the general insurance market. In Australia for example, there has been a continuation of the trend toward fewer providers, which began in the mid 1990s.
SECTOR OUTLOOK
US equities
It appears that some of the impediments to US corporate earnings growth are receding. Concerns about the Iraq situation have faded, the inventory retrenchment has been completed and consumer confidence is in the process of being rebuilt. The return to sustainable positive earnings growth will be gradual; what is important is that it translates into higher capital spending.
A wide range of US companies are likely to benefit. In particular, our managers currently favour technology equipment manufacturers and selected consumer cyclical exposures.
Non-US equities
European equities have the most appealing valuation characteristics. Their recent performance has been driven by forced selling from financial institutions, which was always going to be a temporary phenomenon. The UK equities market contains many attractively priced multi-nationals, with mobile telecommunications and pharmaceuticals our favoured holdings.
Japanese equities have hit new 20-year lows and a recovery remains dependent on aggressive restructuring of the financial sector. Our managers are avoiding the Japanese banking sector in particular.
Australasian equities
Despite the challenges posed by low business confidence and high levels of household debt we remain positive on selected Australasian equities. The attractive cash flow yields of a number of companies compare favourably with both short and long-term interest rates and we consider any downside to be minimal, especially given our belief that monetary policy settings are more likely to be eased than tightened.
Australasian property
We have reduced our exposure to property and infrastructure reflecting the relative out-performance of this asset class in the past 12 months. However, we remain positive on property, and believe performance will be underpinned by low interest rates and deceleration of growth in the broad economy. Given the composition of New Zealand’s prevailing net inward migration trends we favour retail property assets over industrial and commercial property.
US fixed income
The low level of real yields and the higher federal deficit outlook are combining to make US government fixed income assets decidedly unattractive. While the bond market has not yet moved a great deal, any signs of a rebound in spending and activity in the economy will have a detrimental effect on the market.
Non-US fixed income
Yields on European bonds are now more attractively priced than US bonds and this helps to explain the increase in interest in the euro currency. European economic growth rates appear less likely to reaccelerate than the US, and upside risks in yields are less significant.
Australasian fixed income
The Australian and New Zealand bond markets have range-traded so far this year, with a bias toward better performance than many other bond markets. This can be attributed to higher real interest rates and strongly performing currencies. However, it does not mean that the local economies are free from any imbalances. Household debt levels have risen rapidly and are amongst the highest in the world. Although higher house prices and lower funding costs reduce the burden of this debt, it is our view that Australia and New Zealand interest rates need to remain high to attract foreign investment.
Currencies
Currency volatility continues to cause difficulties for exporters, central banks and investors. It is our view that the New Zealand dollar is now close to fair value against the US dollar and somewhat overvalued against the Australian currency.
ARCUS’ MARKET ASSESSMENT
With more clarity of the Iraq situation, markets have begun the second quarter in a position better able to evaluate the economic outlook without the fog of war – and the removal of war concerns are already having a positive effect on consumer sentiment and spending. We expect confidence in the economic recovery to gradually improve and risk premiums implied by asset prices to slowly reduce.
The one asset class where there has been a substantial adjustment in risk-premia over recent times is international equities. While corporate earnings are growing from a depressed level, they are not accelerating swiftly enough to attract a wave of reinvestment into this asset class. We believe that the risk aversion investors feel toward equities will fade only gradually, but during this process equity returns will be able to outpace the low returns from cash and bonds.
Local equity markets have not received the extreme re-rating as international equities, however they do not share the concerns around earnings quality, pension liabilities and excess capacity that plague overseas markets. We believe the Australian and New Zealand equity markets share similar attractive valuation characteristics to international markets and possibly lower risk characteristics. Recent surprise earnings downgrades in the local market however remind us not to be complacent about risks in this market.
Fixed income investments are popular with investors seeking to reduce portfolio risk. We remain concerned however that many fixed income assets carry risks and that the increase in market volatility in shares and currencies may also show up in bond markets.
Commenting is closed
|
|
Good Returns Investment Centre is brought to you by:
Subscribe Now
Keep up to date with the latest investment news Subscribe to our newsletter today
Edison Investment Research
© 2024 Edison Investment Research.
View more research papers »
Today's Best Bank Rates
Heartland Bank |
6.30 |
|
Rabobank |
6.30 |
|
Based on a $50,000 deposit More Rates » |
Heartland Bank |
6.10 |
|
Rabobank |
6.10 |
|
Based on a $50,000 deposit More Rates » |
|
|
|