tmmonline.nz  |   landlords.co.nz        About Good Returns  |  Advertise  |  Contact Us  |  Terms & Conditions  |  RSS Feeds

NZ's Financial Adviser News Centre

GR Logo
Last Article Uploaded: Friday, November 1st, 10:39AM

News

rss
Latest Headlines

Australasian shares more tax efficient than cash

How much default KiwiSaver investors’ pay in tax and the surprising disparity between the tax treatment of different assets has been revealed by Morningstar.

Wednesday, September 19th 2012, 6:30AM 8 Comments

by Benn Bathgate

The KiwiSaver After-Tax Performance Survey revealed the Tax Cost Ratio –the amount of tax KiwiSaver funds pay on their assets – for all the default funds bar Mercer, which failed to submit its data by the Morningstar deadline.

The survey revealed default funds managed by AMP, ASB, AXA, OnePath and Tower paid between 1.30% and 1.92% of their assets in taxes.

Morningstar co-head of research, Chris Douglas, said that while tax is a determining factor in fund returns, “investors and advisers should be wary about selecting investments on the basis of the likelihood of the amount of tax which will need to be paid.”

The survey also revealed the differing tax treatment of various asset classes, and how efficient Australasian equities are compared to other asset classes.

For instance cash had a tax cost ratio of 0.8% and 0.82% for one and three year periods compared to Australasian equities which came in at 0.50% and 0.22% in those periods.

Morninstar says a Tax Cost Ratio of zero indicates that a fund is very tax-efficient, while a 5% Tax Cost Ratio indicates a less tax-efficient offering. For example, if a fund had a 2% Tax Cost Ratio for the three-year time period, it means that on average each year, tax cost an investor 2% of their return.

Douglas said that an absence of capital gains tax on New Zealand and Australian shares meant they were even more tax efficient than cash.

“In fact, when imputation credits are taken into account, we have heard of some KiwiSaver funds providing investors with tax refunds,” he said.

International assets are taxed differently. Any geographical tilts in the investments owned by KiwiSaver funds will therefore have a meaningful impact on the tax paid."

The survey also revealed the vast majority of total KiwiSaver funds under management, 40.2%, is invested in cash and New Zealand bonds.

International shares and international bonds were the only other two categories to have double-digit amounts of KiwiSaver cash invested at 20.3% and 19% respectively.

Despite its tax efficiency, New Zealand and Australian shares account for just 9.5% and 4.6% respectively of KiwiSaver cash.

“A lot of them [KiwiSaver fund managers] are looking to diversify across global equities as well as New Zealand and Australia,” said Douglas.

“But we’re a very small part of the world and a very concentrated market with some very sector-specific concentrations.”

Benn Bathgate is a business reporter for ASSET and Good Returns, email story ideas to benn@goodreturns.co.nz

« AMP research partners under reviewFund managers call for level playing field »

Special Offers

Comments from our readers

On 21 September 2012 at 5:18 pm Phil Harris said:
Thats really interesting. So given that a kiwisaver investor had $10,000 invested in a 100% cash fund with a PIR of 17.50%, with an average earning of 5%pa the investor would pay just $4.00 in tax, rather than $87.50?
This seems semi plausible as an average tax rate on funds with higher growth orientations in the absence of capital gains tax but cash funds do not have that advantage.
I'm wondering if the average tax take of 1.30% to 1.92% for default providers is across all funds or just the default funds themselves? If so the article is highly misleading.
On 22 September 2012 at 11:27 am Waterfall said:
Not sure how much you can read into a Tax Cost Ratio. If a fund makes no money it will have a zero Tax Cost Ratio - the ratio is telling us to buy poor performers to minimise tax! A high ratio (ie the fund is paying a lot of tax) also means investors are making a good return.... While there are clear disparities in NZ tax (FDR, no capital gains taxes etc) the simple Tax Cost Ratio doesn't seem to give investors any useful information.
On 23 September 2012 at 10:25 am More transparency said:
Australian shares are not more tax efficient for an NZ investor than NZ shares. Firstly NZ investors cannot benefit from Australian franking credits so there is a huge tax inefficiency. Secondly NZ shares have higher dividend rates than Australian companies - meaning higher taxable income. Looking simply at the tax paid at fund level does not account for these differences.
On 24 September 2012 at 5:56 pm brent sheather said:
agree with waterfall..this tax cost ratio is nonsense..
On 25 September 2012 at 9:24 am Kimble said:
Ummm, if a fund makes no money, you may still have to pay tax thanks to the FDR. Brent, wasnt that the subject of your Herald opinion piece?!
On 25 September 2012 at 7:03 pm Chris Douglas said:
I’m Chris Douglas from Morningstar, and I’d like to respond to the comments above. Apologies for the length of the response, but there are a few issues to cover.

Firstly, we believe that the Tax Cost Ratio is a useful measure for accurately displaying the tax impacts on a PIE fund, especially for peer analysis. PIE funds pay tax in a variety of ways, none of which have any discernible relationship with the return of the fund. Rather, the tax paid is driven by where the assets are invested. In most cases, investors will pay tax on a PIE fund whether it makes a gain or a loss.

Australasian share investments are taxed only on dividends, and therefore while a fund’s total return could be low or negative, investors pay tax on the income, which for some securities can be in the mid- to high single-digits. International assets are subject to the Fair Dividend Rate (FDR) of five percent, so irrespective of the return that will attract a tax liability. We believe that the Tax Cost Ratio also ties in nicely with the other cost to investors - fees. We display the two side-by-side in our KiwiSaver After-Tax Performance Survey.

The other possible option we assessed was an effective tax rate (ETR). However, we found a number of issues with this. For example, if you have an international share fund with an 0.10 percent total return, and it’s paying tax on the FDR, investors could end up with a 160.0 percent ETR.

We encourage readers to read our full report and explanation of the Tax Cost Ratio and the quirks of the PIE tax regime at www.morningstar.co.nz. We’re also happy to answer other questions – please contact us directly.

Finally, in response to Phil Harris, if you had a KiwiSaver fund with NZ$10,000 and had a Tax Cost Ratio of 1.30 - 1.920 percent, you would be paying around NZ$130 - 192 in tax.
On 25 September 2012 at 7:38 pm brent sheather said:
yes that is right..even if fees consume all the dividend income under FDR you can still be levied for tax at 5% but if international shares returned 40% that year it would have an attractive tax cost ratio..assuming I understand how this thing works and I have never heard of this measure before which probably isn't surprising either..lol
On 26 September 2012 at 12:08 pm JohnB said:
Chris - thanks. Still not convinced the Tax Cost Ratio (TCR) allows useful comparisons between different asset classes as the article suggests (Oz equities vs cash).
Within an asset class the TCR can also be problematic - i.e. for cash funds high return (good thing) means high TCR (bad thing).
Tax paid relative to net income (Effective Tax Rate or ETR) rather than relative to fund size is more useful. Where FDR applies the TCR will show a much lower result in the "bad" years (i.e. favourable for fund managers). But from the investor perspective the ETR shows the reality of tax paid - ie your example where tax is 160% of net income. That is the unfortunate reality of FDR tax in a bad year. (Hope references to ETR, TCR and FDR haven't confused everyone!).

Sign In to add your comment

 

print

Printable version  

print

Email to a friend
News Bites
Latest Comments
Subscribe Now

Weekly Wrap

Previous News
Most Commented On
Mortgage Rates Table

Full Rates Table | Compare Rates

Lender Flt 1yr 2yr 3yr
AIA - Back My Build 5.44 - - -
AIA - Go Home Loans 7.99 5.99 5.69 5.69
ANZ 7.89 6.59 6.29 6.29
ANZ Blueprint to Build 7.39 - - -
ANZ Good Energy - - - 1.00
ANZ Special - 5.99 5.69 5.69
ASB Bank 7.89 5.99 5.69 5.69
ASB Better Homes Top Up - - - 1.00
Avanti Finance 8.40 - - -
Basecorp Finance 9.60 - - -
BNZ - Classic - 5.99 5.69 5.69
Lender Flt 1yr 2yr 3yr
BNZ - Mortgage One 7.94 - - -
BNZ - Rapid Repay 7.94 - - -
BNZ - Std 7.94 5.99 5.69 5.69
BNZ - TotalMoney 7.94 - - -
CFML 321 Loans 6.20 - - -
CFML Home Loans 6.45 - - -
CFML Prime Loans 8.25 - - -
CFML Standard Loans 9.20 - - -
China Construction Bank - 7.09 6.75 6.49
China Construction Bank Special - - - -
Co-operative Bank - First Home Special - 5.79 - -
Lender Flt 1yr 2yr 3yr
Co-operative Bank - Owner Occ 7.65 5.99 5.75 5.69
Co-operative Bank - Standard 7.65 6.49 6.25 6.19
Credit Union Auckland 7.70 - - -
First Credit Union Special - 6.40 6.10 -
First Credit Union Standard 8.50 7.00 6.70 -
Heartland Bank - Online 7.49 ▼5.65 ▼5.55 ▼5.55
Heartland Bank - Reverse Mortgage - - - -
Heretaunga Building Society 8.90 7.00 6.50 -
ICBC 7.49 5.99 5.65 5.59
Kainga Ora 8.39 7.05 6.59 6.49
Kainga Ora - First Home Buyer Special - - - -
Lender Flt 1yr 2yr 3yr
Kiwibank 7.75 6.89 6.59 6.49
Kiwibank - Offset 8.25 - - -
Kiwibank Special 7.75 5.99 5.69 5.69
Liberty 8.59 8.69 8.79 8.94
Nelson Building Society 8.44 ▼6.39 ▼6.09 -
Pepper Money Advantage 10.49 - - -
Pepper Money Easy 8.69 - - -
Pepper Money Essential 8.29 - - -
SBS Bank 7.99 6.95 6.29 6.29
SBS Bank Special - ▼6.15 5.69 5.69
SBS Construction lending for FHB - - - -
Lender Flt 1yr 2yr 3yr
SBS FirstHome Combo 5.44 ▼5.15 - -
SBS FirstHome Combo - - - -
SBS Unwind reverse equity 9.75 - - -
TSB Bank 8.69 6.79 6.49 6.49
TSB Special 7.89 5.99 5.69 5.69
Unity ▼7.64 5.99 5.69 -
Unity First Home Buyer special - 5.49 - -
Wairarapa Building Society 8.50 ▼6.19 ▼5.79 -
Westpac 8.39 6.89 6.39 6.39
Westpac Choices Everyday 8.49 - - -
Westpac Offset 8.39 - - -
Lender Flt 1yr 2yr 3yr
Westpac Special - 6.29 5.79 5.79
Median 7.99 6.17 5.79 5.69

Last updated: 30 October 2024 9:36am

About Us  |  Advertise  |  Contact Us  |  Terms & Conditions  |  Privacy Policy  |  RSS Feeds  |  Letters  |  Archive  |  Toolbox  |  Disclaimer
 
Site by Web Developer and eyelovedesign.com