Z Energy, Synlait crash on earnings downgrades

New Zealand shares fell as investors punished fuel retailer Z Energy and dairy processor Synlait Milk for earnings downgrades.

Thursday, September 12th 2019, 6:43PM

by BusinessDesk

The S&P/NZX 50 Index was 19.82 points, or 0.2 percent, lower at 10,905.06. Within the index, 26 stocks fell, 22 rose, and two were unchanged. Turnover was $121.5 million, of which Z accounted for $17.3 million and Synlait $5 million.

Matt Goodson, managing director at Salt Funds Management, said the market has had a very strong start to September, despite the fact that company earnings haven't matched that optimism.

Z Energy led the market lower after cutting its earnings guidance by $60 million, most of which it blamed on "unprecedented" discounting among petrol retailers, coinciding with the Commerce Commission's market study of the sector. The stock slumped 9.8 percent to an eight-month low $5.68 on a volume of 3 million, more than four times its 90-day average of 619,000. It was the most traded stock today.

"Z Energy really did surprise. They held an investor day quite recently where there wasn't the slightest hint of trouble and yet came out today and informed the market that the chief thing they're seeing is very sharp price competition and also what appears to be difficulties changing over loyalty schemes," Goodson said.

Synlait was close behind, dropping 9.2 percent to a three-month low $8.75 on volume of 564,000 shares, well up on its 90,000 daily average. The milk processor lifted annual profit by 10 percent as revenue cracked a billion dollars for the first time, but disappointed analysts with its 2020 forecast.

"Synlait Milk's result was a little bit below expectations, but their forward guidance appears a reasonable amount below current forecasts," Goodson said.

A2 Milk declined 1.7 percent to $14.28. Synlait noted A2 had negotiated better prices during the July 2019 financial year. Fonterra Shareholders' Fund units were down 1.9 percent at $3.17.

Goodson said the increase in global bond yields over the past couple of weeks triggered a rotation in asset allocations, with investors selling stocks offering reliable yields or growth opportunities and buying value.

Fisher & Paykel Healthcare fell 2.3 percent to $16.51, Vector was down 1.7 percent at $3.57 and Genesis Energy fell 1.4 percent to $3.48 with 1 million shares changing hands.

Fletcher Building rose 2 percent to $5.10 on a volume of 1.8 million shares and Sky Network Television was up 1.8 percent at $1.14.

Mercury NZ was down 0.6 percent, or 3 cents, at $5.30 after shedding rights to a 9.3 cent per share dividend on a volume of 1 million shares. Precinct Properties New Zealand, STride Property, Freightways, Vista Group International and Metlifecare all moved lower as they shed dividends.

Oceania Healthcare was unchanged at $1.02 after saying it received resource consent for the redevelopment of a site in south Auckland.

Contact Energy posted the day's biggest gain, up 2.7 percent at $8.68 on a volume of 691,000 shares, less than its 986,000 daily average. SkyCity Entertainment Group rose 2 percent to $4.06 on a volume of 1.2 million shares.

Goodman Property Trust rose 0.7 percent to $2.23 on a volume of 1.5 million units after buying a mixed-use property in Auckland for $65 million. T&G Global sold the property and has signed up to a two-year lease, which can be extended for another two years. The fruit exporter was unchanged at $2.55.

Of other stocks trading on volumes of more than a million shares, Spark New Zealand rose 1.7 percent to $4.50, Kiwi Property Group decreased 0.3 percent to $1.665, and Meridian Energy increased 0.2 percent to $5.09.

Outside the benchmark index, NZME fell 1.2 percent to a new all-time low of 42 cents. Jarden reiterated its 'neutral' rating on the stock today, and said very poor earnings from rival Stuff may encourage the publishers to revive their attempts for one to buy the other.

Chorus's 2028 bonds paying annual interest of 4.35 percent were the most traded debt security on a volume of 2 million. The notes closed at a yield of 2.65 percent, up 10 basis points. Chorus shares rose 0.3 percent to $5.11.

Tags: Market Close